Saturday, June 6, 2009

Arrival to amazing Hanoi National Convention Center


The Congress met today and we had a lot of fun meeting with poeple from so many countries. Our hosts really entertained us with music and gracious support and we listened to the President of Vietnam and others speak of peace and justice. It is late and I will write more but I wanted to upload some pics for you all to enjoy and watch tomorrow for dozens of pics and even some footage.









Go to http://www.flickr.com/photos/sirotkin/sets/72157619266349131/ for a temporary look at 51 photos from Day one. Tags and descriptions added soon.

Enjoy. You can see that we are. Other delegates will write soon. Good night.

Eric Sirotkin
Ashland Oregon

Friday, June 5, 2009

Seeking Progressive Changes from the Heart of Hanoi

Hanoi has the most unique traffic pyramid I have ever encountered. One where an entity's size -- whether a vehicle, rickshaw, cart, or pedestrian -- determines its power on the road. Irrespective of this sheer physical and phenotypical power, pedestrians and stray animals push their way through the never ending waves of motor bikes and occasional SUVs amidst the very narrow city roads, where streets too are populated with parked motor-bikes. This power-play on Hanoi's roads is analogous to state-state interactions in international law, which makes it a wonderfully appropo place to host this year's annual IADL conference. The conference will be discussing issues central to contemporary International Law: Right to Peace, Accountability in the Internatinal Criminal Court System, an Independent Judiciary, ESC Rights, and the Right to Development and Environmental Security.

I came to the conference with very little knowledge about NLG's International Committee and the IADL in general. However, the introduction meeting today clarified the history and the objectives of the conference. As we feasted over various vegetarian dishes in Hanoi's old quarter, Jeannie Myers, the current Secretary-General of the IADL gave us brief intro to the organization and the conference itself. IADL was founded in 1946 by the prosecutors of the Nuremberg trial, with the objective of creating an international coalition of lawyers to realize the principles of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, further enshrined in conventions like the CCPRs, and CESRs. It has lawyer-members from over 100 countries, and they collectively attempt to carry out the struggle against violations of these foundational principals of modern international law. The conference will be attended by over 220 legal practitioners and students, and the President of Vietnam will give the plenary talk!!

Regardless of the fan and flare of the line-up, what I found most interesting were the career paths of the lawyers with whom I met. I would say over half of the 16 or so lawyers present had worked directly on labor and employment issues across America, and almost all had served as staunch opponents of the Vietnam War (and presumably Iraq too!). In fact, Jeannie spend the last 10 years of her career to use legal avenues to bring compensation to the victims of Agent Orange via American war-tactics during the 60s and 70s. It was refreshing to see American lawyers working on justice issues across the world, from Human Trafficking issues in Tajikistan, to human rights promotion in post-conflict Bosnia and Croatia to serving as defense counsel at the ICTR to pushing for peace on the Korean peninsula to suing oil companies for their misadventures in Nigeria to working with advocacy groups in Venezuela & Cuba. It was pretty inspiring to be sitting among a group of folks who were reaching beyond the rhetoric to make things happen, and hopefully this would serve as a good segway into tomorrow's events!

Anurag Gupta,
NYU Law School

Let the Games Begin


Lawyers and law students from all across the US gathered here in Hanoi today for a great veggie feast at the Tamarind restaurant (conveniently located right across from the Elegance Hotel). It was great seeing everyone excited about Vietnam and being here. We first met with a representative from the Vietnam Lawyers Association who brought us gift briefcases, our manual with the translated papers and a gift for everyone. The event starts tomorrow and we head early to the Convention Center. The President of Vietnam comes to address us tomorrow. We will try and tape it and get it up to watch. Banners hang around town welcoming the IADL.

Art and Sandy had just gotten back from a boat trip on Halong Bay. Beautiful caves and rock formations and some kayaking too. Marjorie was sharing with some students and others her first trip to China just after Mao died in 1977 with the Lawyers Guild. Several people had just arrived and more are still coming in. What was most exciting was to hear the wealth of experience as people went around and talked about their work and lives. Michael Sorgen shared his work in the 60's where they actually got a Federal Judge to declare the Vietnam War illegal and tracked his work forward through stop-Loss challenges and other cases. Law Students shared their experiences in finding the Guild and how inspiring it was to be here. Tiger Beer and Carrot Juice flowed freely. Watch for everyone's blog entries in the coming days.

Eric Sirotkin
Ashland, Oregon

Thursday, June 4, 2009

Awakening to Vietnam











The beauty of the lotus flower here in Vietnam rising out of the depths of such struggle and darkness to bloom ever brighter.


On the Headset on the way to Vietnam Tim Buckley (Yes Jeff Buckley’s dad to those of a younger era) is singing that amazing and powerful song from the stunningly complex and heart-filled anti-war film with Jon Voight, Bruce Dern and Jane Fonda - Coming Home. A poem that goes straight through the heart.

“Once I was a soldier
and I fought on foreign sands for you
Once I was a hunter
and I brought home fresh meat for you.

Once I was a lover
and i searched behind your eyes for you.
Oh but soon they’ll be another
to tell you I was just a lie.


But sometimes,
I wonder
just for a while.
....will you ever remember me.

Though you have forgotten 
All of our rubbish dreams...I find myself searching
through the ashes of our ruins.

For the days when we smiled
and the hours that ran wild
with the magic of our eyes
and the silent of our worlds

But sometimes
I wonder
Just for a while.
Will you ever
ever, ever,
remember me.

Coming to Vietnam was to be a healing journey. I never served the war, but as a teenager I took to the streets. It was my parents who first took me to an anti-war demonstration - even to Washington for the Moratorium of 1969. Soon after I went with friends to DC for mass
gatherings for peace in 1971 and in the counter-Nixon inauguration of 500,000+ in 1972. Cold in January but warming for the heart on so many levels.

Yet this trip is showing me how traumatized we still are as Americans from this war. More than 50,000 US troop deaths, but even deeper was the continuation of the erosion of the American illusion as liberator and freedom fighter. The integrity gained in liberating Europe was quickly lost as the atomic bombs shattered kids on tricycles in Japan and in the US carpet bombing and horrific acts in Korea. The cycle of violence continues to haunt us to this day.

In the US we became stuck in the past - frozen in time in our images and stereotypes. For despite some hearings on a few high profile massacres and the discussion of the PTSD war trauma of soldiers, we have yet to learn a new way of relating from this experience with those with which we have strong differences (See Iraq, DPRK etc).

For me as an American caught in the legacy of shame from the Vietnam War, I too find myself trapped in the sounds of war. I can walk around the lake in Hanoi and hear air raid sirens and feel a chill, while here Vietnamese lovers watch the sunset. While floating on the river in the stillness it can be muffled by the sound in my head of gunfire or my mind scanning the high grass along the bank - feeling the fear that must have been so pervasive.

All of this and I never fought here or visited here. The body memories of the GI’s must be so deep and painful. I think by being here you get that strongly.

The take on the Recruitment poster with Uncle Sam comes to mind “"Join the Army - travel to distant lands; meet exciting, unusual people and kill them....” When will we learn that this cannot work. Like Obama said yesterday in Cairo “Violence cannot work.” We need to apply that to our own dealings around the world.

However, the country here had move than 5 million casualties in maimed and killed civilians and soldiers. Incomprehensible to us. Yet, the shocking thing to me is how much laughter, joy and hospitality I experience and observe. I see a very proud people - the victors in war and struggle - about to celebrate their 1000 year history as a city - declaring themselves to be “The City For Peace.” Most of the people here are under age 35. They have never known war. Perhaps they lost grandparents to the war, but they now focus on fashion, work, school, cell phones and coffee houses.

I too begin to change. The sounds that echoed in my mind begin to fade and I am left with the sparkling reflection of the water, the plumeria petals filling the steps to the temple or the smile of a fisherman. I then begin to understand.










We only heal when we re-write our story - or at least turn the page. We heal when we face the quiet demons that have been trapped through thoughts or experiences and enjoy the essence of being human. Ubuntu means we are human only through or relations with other human beings. Its the C S & N song Wooden Ships: “Smile at me and I will understand.”Bringing the world closer is the key. Even here in the “Socialist Republic of Vietnam” we have more in common than we know.

We can’t rewrite the cruelty of war. But here in Vietnam they rebuilt a sacred pagoda that the French had purposely blown up as they were exiting their occupation in Vietnam. The tourist still come to the “ancient” pagoda - with its fresh rebuilt concrete base - to celebrate something older than brick and mortar. It’s a continuum that endures and I am here to celebrate and join the side of life that refuses to let hope die, but wishes to, despite adversity, continue to celebrate the amazing journey of life.

Posted by Eric Sirotkin

Monday, June 1, 2009

Equal Brothers

The next day I spent in Inteawon, a multi-cultural commercial district near the US army base to eat a little different food. The thousands out on the Saturday night were far away - both from the Police lines of City Hall and any understanding of the issues facing the divided Korea. A nuclear Bomb had exploded underground in a country 30 miles away, but few here in the streets seemed to care. Young people I spoke with in the classroom when I asked them if the state of war and the nuclear test made them scared said simply...it’s just North Korea again.

It will take some pushing on both sides of the ocean to get the leaders to awaken to the fact that war/sanctions/isolation will never lead to peace. As Gandhi said, “There is no way to peace. Peace is the way.”

This is the problem with Obama surrounding himself with so many of the “experienced” foreign affairs people from prior administrations. They don’t accept that change is needed and think that what they did before was on track, instead of outdated. The Clinton folks just don’t get it. Few of the players int eh higher positions have been bold players. I believe Obama wants to lead in a new direction, but it will take him having the time to lead and realizing that a comprehensive bi-lateral peace is needed -not the same old 6 party crawl. Relationship is not a reward in international affairs - it is a PRE-requisite.

In my last hours in Korea I decided to visit the Korea War Memorial. No I’m not a gluten for gore and punishment, but knew it would be a treasure chest of B Roll footage and photos for any future film, You Tube etc. It was mammoth and oddly enough had attached to it a huge kids play area and a wedding Hall. “Hey hun. Lets get hitched at the old war museum.” I guess everyone has a different notion of romance. It reminded me of the “Victorious Fatherland Liberation War Museum” in Pyeongyang, though the description of the war varies greatly. It had a “DMZ” Cafeteria. 

I wonder how they will grapple with the Truth Commission findings when they are complete. They clearly need to be included, but what is generally absent in most “war” museums is an honest critique about the horrors of war, unless inflicted by the other side, or any failings or wrongdoing of the “fatherland.” Yet, its never so black and white. I was impressed at Hiroshima where the museum was devoted to the dangers of aggression in general, including Japanese imperialist aggression. However, the difference is that they were memorializing the “peace” and it is known as a “peace” park and museum. Hmmm.

What also drew me there was I’d read that there was a “brothers” statute of two embracing soldiers from the North and South, “a symbol o the hope of reunification.” As I walked through a wall like the Vietnam Wall with the names of the lost soldiers, I emerged at the huge brothers statute. I was so disappointed. It was a huge South Korean soldier with a rifle hugging a tiny DPRK soldier who had no weapons - a clear symbol that brothers are united when the North has given up and surrendered to the South. Strip off the rifle and give them comparable stature and we’d have a powerful symbol of peace and reunification. That would be the approach of a peace museum. I left sad. This oft-dysfunctional family has a way to go in a world that still memorializes war and demonizes peace. I’m drawn to a Korean Poem that the TRC uses in its material:

Daffodils of the Sea
by Seo Young-sun

I am an ever tragic bird
I am wandering in a dark cave and a deep valley.
Hit by a wave, my soul cannot fly
The sky is torn and the earth is divided
My soul has been wandering for half a century.

My wounds have not yet healed over the many years.
Time has passed, but nothing seems resolved.
I wish I could see eternity.
I hope our dearest wish can move the heavens
And the heavens send us fresh spring water
ad peaceful doves.

Free Speech and a Sea of Seoul Blue

When I arrived to the top of the City Hall Metro steps I was blocked by a sea of blue police helmets. Young kids really. Decked out in the costume primed for street warfare, in outfits that were a cross between a serious lacrosse player and Iron Man. Behind the caged face guards you could catch their expressions of “How did I get here?” Few seemed to have the anger and personal agenda of the US riot patrols (ala www.committingpoetry.com), as most are consigned to the job for just two years as an alternative to South Korean compulsory military service.
I have never seen so many police in one place. Their buses had encircled Seoul Plaza - the historic gathering place for prior successful anti-government rallies - no one got in or out all week except on the day of the funeral. The units moved around in clumps, ever letting anyone effectively assemble.

As in America there days, the designated free speech zones were set miles away- far from the visible City Center and historic mecca for candlelight vigils and the street battles of democratizations. The police quite consciously moved each squad from corner to corner - often in step and chanting like soldiers at boot camp. They would veer around baby strollers or couple arm in arm. Until they grew tired of my filming from the island strip, we were allowed to stay in place or move about unimpeded when we could get around their dense lines.

Here is a brief report I did on site. Thanks to Joe Cha for filming.


They seemed to go intensely around anyone who seemed to be upset with their intimidating show of force. A step ladder was used to rise up over the crowd so that they could take photos or at times video of those in that crowd daring to speak up. The message was clear - no assembly - no speech.

While filming on the island someone suddenly called my name. There was John Cha - whom I had met earlier this year in Berkeley. We had spent a great evening with many other Korea activists at a dinner when the Commissioner was speaking. John is working on a book on separated families - the personal stories behind the politics. It was a familiar face and welcome relief among the sea of blue intimidation.

After being ordered off the island (shades of Albuquerque, but without the gun in my face), John and I and his son Joe headed back to Insadong close to my hotel where he knew of a local knock on the door drinking hole called aptly Pyunghwa mahn deul ki - Making of Peace. There I downed a whole pitcher...of water...while we swapped Korea stories. His son Joe was from San Francisco and knew of my stepson Sam’s work so I shared pics of his latest show ( http://arrestedmotion.com/2009/05/openings-sam-flores-exhibitionsubliminal-projects/) and he told me he had a Flores T-Shirt with him on that trip. Small world.

Bury my heart at Gyeongsan

Yesterday the country gathered to honor President Roh (Pronounced Noh by Koreans.) As you can see in the papers, it was a mass gathering with a sea of yellow (his campaign color) filling the streets outside the invite only funeral within the old palace’s walls. 
Inside some tension arose wen a courageous Assemblyman, Back Won Woo, rushed at current President Lee shouting “Don’t lay the flowers. How dare you come here. You must apologize! You have murdered him in political retaliation.” As he was being taken away he cried out ”President Lee must apologize to President Roh.” And when Lee approached Roh’s family to offer his condolences, Roh’s son turned his face away. The cry heard throughout the week from his supporters filtered into the speech by his former prime minister saying “we’re sorry we abandoned you. We’re sorry we left you alone.”
It’s true the mass movements that ushered him into office had been relatively silent as his successor’s prosecutorial agents went after Roh with a vengeance. people in the movement, often stymied or frustrated by the new conservative government, realized they had let him down. Yet, Roh chose some degree of self-imposed exile at his southern house/farm and, thought becoming an active blogger, appeared to enjoy being out of the limelight of public office. Of course as with any politician his period in office was not always 100% in line with his supporters who often had trouble with his sending troops to Iraq, the dispossession of farmers from Pyongtaek for the U.S. military relocation and the signing of the Korean Free Trade Agreement. Yet, he boldly engaged the North and called on Washington to enter a peace treaty - something that fell silent in the Bush years.

I did not stay in the sea of people around the he funeral and would only return to Seoul Plaza at dusk. This would be the only time that a rally was allowed to take place on the historic plaza, as by nightfall hundreds of police buses would encircle the plaza and block access.
Instead the TRC took me a couple of hundred miles south to the Gyeongsan Cobalt Mine - of the ten (and largest to date) excavations sites from massacres by South Korean soldiers during the early Korean War. While not directly attributable to U.S. Soldiers, it was part of a mass execution of lefties policy carried out with U.S. knowledge. More than 100,000 died in this fashion according to the government sponsored TRC.

The Japanese had built the mine in 1937, but it had ceased operation by 1944. Today it is located behind a nursing home and borders a country club and gold course, with a small lake where people float by in boats not knowing or acknowledging that just below lie the bones of thousands of victims of horror. In fact several deep holes on the golf course were filled in during its construction and it was well-known in the area that all of these mine shafts and holes had been filled with bodies arriving by the truckload.

Two members of the local aggrieved families group accompanied us down the mine shaft. But first they took us into see some of the bones that have been gathered. Before the TRC took over, the family groups had gotten others to support their excavation. Many of the bones were used as examples to lobby hard for establishment of the TRC. In fact, one of the members with us had gone to New York with 8 others in 2001, when our group, the International Association of Democratic Lawyers (IADL), whoa re holding the conference next week in Hanoi, helped put on a Tribunal on US War Crimes in Korea. (See Report at our site www.nlg,org/korea). They had raised the money for all their expenses and brought some of the pre-TRC evidence to reveal some of the hidden truth about the war.

I slowly circled the shed with its assorted trays of skulls, femurs, bullets and teeth. Only the femurs can be used for an accurate count. I have had my share of sites of grief. I have been to Hiroshima and felt its painful imprints. In South Africa I listened to stories of great torture and unspeakable crimes, and visited Mandela’s cell and the the stone quarries of Robbin island. In the North of Korea I felt the fire-charred walls of the bomb shelter in Sinchon, where women and children and other civilians were burnt to death when US troops placed dynamite and gasoline down the air vents of the shelters. Yet, here the trays and trays of bones brought home in graphic terms how “civilization” has shelves and shelves of tears. As my boys sing in their Generation Prodigy song: “Sad eyes are leakin’ tears. Too much pain the world today.”

I will never forget the skull with the clear bullet hole, amazingly preserved, like a message from the past - pleading with us to end the madness.
Upon opening the door to the mine a huge icy breeze shot out - as if in one of those horror films where suddenly you can see your breath just before the candle goes out. The locals used to call it the “ice cave” and in the heat of summer some would picnic at the opening oblivious to the horrors just below the surface.

We donned large rubber boots as water flows along the floor. Traveling deep into the mine, hands raised to guide us along the low lying ceiling, I glanced back and saw the light of the entrance fade in the distance. Two flashlights lit the path ahead. When we reached the center we could see the vertical shaft where many of the bodies were dropped. A pond concealed the bones that were protruding from the wall below, as they were a few weeks from excavating the next more extensive layer. Some bones were found near the entrance which tells them that some people may have tried to crawl out after being shot and dropped. Our guide, a Ph’d anthropologist who heads the TRC excavation teams, used a stick to separate off the algae in the water to try and show us the bones below.

Gratefully we emerged into the bright light of the day and I took note of how the pine trees along the hillside seemed more alive and vibrant than when we entered. As we spoke with the family members the birds in the trees started singing a beautiful melody.

Back at their local office I met a woman who’s lost both her parents in the mine massacres. At ten she was an orphan. I held her hands as we walked up the stairs. She had lost her husband as well at age 30. Children of alleged leftists were denied work and hounded. But she still had such an infectious smile. She told me she was all alone and that this struggle for justice was all she had. She wishes to honor the dead through an apology or acknowledgment and some form of reparations. It was clear that the aggrieved families bond had become her surrogate family.
It was here that the bones became live with flesh and broken hearts. On the train home I would listen to the rest of the guys’ “Sad Eyes” song and it was so healing :
You can’t erase,
what’s before today.
But you can change
so tomorrow’s not the same.
Whatever it is in life,
can’t sleep at night,
there’s time to make it right.